WHA86 Whisky Advocate Summer, 2012
"Along with Cragganmore, this is one of the underrated members of the original Classic Six. Quite why has always slightly baffled me. OK, it isn’t smoky, but the nose has a deep, soft, honeyed sweetness: think caramelized fruits, hints of thick cream, and a light touch of fennel and sharp citrus. Thick in the center and very gentle, it’s that chunkiness in the middle that is the secret to its beauty." (86 pts.)
WE85 Wine Enthusiast 5/1/1997
"Light amber yellow appearance. Moderately full-bodied. Mint, peat, honey, green herbs. Big aromas of honey and herbs lead a very long, smooth palate with an oily feel. Very dry in style." (85 pts.)
WE85+ Wine Enthusiast 4/1/2004
"Opening aromas are assertive, dry, with peppery scents of barley husk, grainy oil and cracked wheat wafer; seven more minutes bring out a mildly sweeter, slightly vanilla bean, brown rice-like side. Palate entry is pleasantly prickly, textured and moderately sweet; at midpalate, the taste profile turns stunningly sappy and resin-like. Finishes dry to off-dry and keenly resiny." (85–89 pts.)
WE87 Wine Enthusiast 12/1/2000
"This medium-gold malt bears notes of heather and a slightly dry peatiness The body is medium, and the palate is creamy with notes of wildflowers and honey that are well balanced with a subtle under blanket of peat. The finish is long and sweet." (87 pts.)